Fretting Fracture â Complete Medical Guide
Overview
A fretting fracture (also called a stress fracture that occurs at a boneâimplant or boneâjoint interface) is a small crack in a bone caused by repetitive, lowâmagnitude loading rather than a single highâimpact event. The term âfrettingâ originally comes from engineering, describing damage that results from tiny backâandâforth motions at a contact point; in orthopedics it describes similar microâmovements that fatigue bone tissue.
These fractures most commonly affect adults who are physically active, but they can also occur in older adults with osteoporotic bone, in people who use prosthetic joints, or in patients who have hardware (screws, plates, rods) after orthopedic surgery.
- Prevalence: Stress fractures (including fretting types) account for 1â2âŻ% of all fractures in the general population and up to 10âŻ% of sportsârelated injuries. In patients with joint replacements, frettingâtype fractures occur in <âŻ0.5âŻ% of cases, but the true incidence may be higher because they are often underâdiagnosed.1,2
- Typical age range: 15â45âŻyears for athleticârelated cases; >65âŻyears for osteoporotic or hardwareârelated cases.
- Gender: Slight female predominance in osteoporosisârelated fractures; male predominance in highâimpact athletes.
Symptoms
Because the crack is tiny, symptoms can be subtle and develop gradually. A complete symptom list includes:
- Localized pain: Dull, aching pain that worsens with activity and eases with rest.
- Point tenderness: Palpable soreness directly over the fracture line.
- Swelling or mild effusion: Usually minimal; may be more pronounced if the fracture is near a joint.
- Mechanical crepitus: A faint clicking or grinding sensation during movement, especially when the fracture is adjacent to an implant.
- Decreased performance: Athletes often notice a drop in strength or endurance before pain becomes obvious.
- Altered gait or limp: When the lower extremity is affected.
- Night pain: Uncommon, but may occur if the fracture progresses.
- Radiating pain: If the fracture is close to a nerve, patients may feel discomfort radiating downstream.
Causes and Risk Factors
Fretting fractures arise when bone experiences repetitive microâtrauma that exceeds its ability to remodel and repair.
Primary Causes
- Repetitive loading: Running, jumping, or marching for long periods.
- Microâmovement at a prosthetic interface: Small shifts of a joint replacement or fixation hardware.
- Sudden increase in activity level: Going from sedentary to highâintensity training too quickly.
Risk Factors
- Low bone mineral density (osteoporosis, osteopenia).
- Female sex, especially preâmenopausal athletes with the âfemale athlete triadâ (low energy availability, menstrual disturbances, low bone mass).
- Vitamin D deficiency (<30âŻng/mL).
- Improper footwear or training surfaces (hard ground, uneven terrain).
- Highâimpact sports (track & field, gymnastics, basketball, military training).
- Previous fracture or boneâstress injury.
- Use of certain medications (corticosteroids, bisphosphonates after longâterm use, protonâpump inhibitors).
- Presence of orthopedic implants that allow micromotion (loosening, suboptimal placement).
Diagnosis
Because early fretting fractures may not be visible on plain Xâray, a stepwise diagnostic approach is recommended.
Clinical Evaluation
- Detailed history focusing on activity changes, joint replacement status, and medication use.
- Physical exam for point tenderness, gait analysis, and rangeâofâmotion testing.
Imaging Studies
- Plain radiographs: Firstâline; may show a faint radiolucent line after 2â3 weeks of symptoms.
- Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI): Gold standard for early detection; shows boneâmarrow edema and the fracture line without radiation exposure.3
- Computed tomography (CT): Helpful for complex anatomic areas (spine, pelvis) or when MRI is contraindicated.
- Bone scintigraphy (technetiumâ99m scan): Highly sensitive but less specific; useful when MRI is unavailable.
- Dualâenergy Xâray absorptiometry (DEXA): Recommended to assess bone density in atârisk patients.
Laboratory Tests (when indicated)
- Serum 25âhydroxy vitamin D, calcium, phosphate, and parathyroid hormone to rule out metabolic bone disease.
- Complete blood count and inflammatory markers (CRP, ESR) if infection or inflammatory arthropathy is suspected.
Treatment Options
The goal is to allow the bone to remodel while preventing progression to a complete fracture.
Conservative Management
- Activity modification: Cease the aggravating activity for 4â6 weeks; crossâtrain with lowâimpact exercises (swimming, cycling).
- Protected weightâbearing: Use crutches or a walking boot if the lower extremity is involved.
- Analgesia: Acetaminophen or NSAIDs (ibuprofen 400â600âŻmg q6â8h) for pain; limit NSAIDs >2âŻweeks to avoid impairing bone healing.4
- Nutrition: Calcium 1,200âŻmg/day + Vitamin D 800â1,000âŻIU/day; consider oral bisphosphonates if osteoporosis is confirmed.
- Physical therapy: Gentle range of motion and strengthening after pain subsides; focus on core stability to reduce lowerâextremity load.
Procedural Interventions
- Immobilization with a cast or boot: For fractures in the tibia, metatarsals, or femur that need more rigidity.
- Surgical fixation: Indicated when the fracture is displaced, fails to heal after 8â12 weeks, or is located at a highâstress site (e.g., femoral neck). Options include percutaneous screw fixation or intramedullary nailing.
- Hardware revision: If a prosthetic component is the source of micromotion, revision surgery to improve fit or add supplemental fixation may be required.
Adjunct Therapies
- Lowâintensity pulsed ultrasound (LIPUS): May accelerate healing in select cases, though evidence is mixed.5
- Electrical bone growth stimulation: Considered for refractory fractures.
Living with Fretting Fracture
Even after the fracture heals, patients often need ongoing strategies to prevent recurrence.
- Gradual return to activity: Follow a âpainâfreeâ stepâup protocolâ10% increase in mileage or intensity per week.
- Footwear assessment: Replace worn shoes every 300â500âŻmiles; choose shoes with adequate shock absorption.
- Strength and flexibility training: Emphasize hip abductors, calf muscles, and core to distribute forces evenly.
- Crossâtraining: Include lowâimpact cardio (elliptical, swimming) to maintain fitness without overloading bone.
- Regular bone health checkâups: DEXA scan every 2â3âŻyears for adults over 50 or earlier if risk factors are present.
- Monitor hardware: For patients with joint replacements, schedule routine orthopedic followâups to assess implant stability.
Prevention
Prevention hinges on minimizing repetitive stress and optimizing bone health.
- Progressive training plans: Increase distance or intensity by no more than 10% per week.
- Strengthen supporting musculature: Target the glutes, quadriceps, and calves to offload the bone.
- Adequate nutrition: 1,200âŻmg calcium and 800â1,000âŻIU vitamin D daily; consider a multivitamin if dietary intake is insufficient.
- Screen for bone loss: Early DEXA for atârisk groups (women >50, men with steroid use).
- Proper footwear and insoles: Use orthotics for abnormal foot biomechanics.
- Rest and recovery: Incorporate at least one rest day per week and allow 48âŻhours between highâimpact sessions.
- Address hormonal factors: Treat menstrual irregularities in female athletes and consider endocrine evaluation for men with low testosterone.
- Regular implant surveillance: For patients with prostheses, follow surgeon recommendations for periodic imaging and clinical exams.
Complications
If a fretting fracture is missed or inadequately treated, several complications can arise:
- Complete fracture: The crack propagates, leading to a displaced fracture that may require surgery.
- Nonâunion or delayed union: Persistent pain >12 weeks; may need surgical intervention.
- Chronic pain syndrome: Ongoing discomfort can limit activity and affect quality of life.
- Hardware failure: In patients with implants, micromotion can cause loosening or breakage of screws/plates.
- Osteoarthritis: Altered joint mechanics after a fracture can accelerate degenerative changes.
- Compartment syndrome: Rare but possible with swelling in the lower leg; an orthopedic emergency.
When to Seek Emergency Care
- Sudden, severe pain that worsens despite rest.
- Visible deformity or an obvious âstep-offâ in the bone.
- Rapid swelling, bruising, or a feeling of the limb âgiving way.â
- Numbness, tingling, or loss of sensation in the foot or hand.
- Inability to bear weight on the affected limb.
- Fever, redness, or drainage around a surgical scarâsigns of infection.
References
- Mayo Clinic. Stress fractures. Updated 2023. https://www.mayoclinic.org
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Fretting Corrosion and Periprosthetic Fractures. 2022. https://www.aaos.org
- NIH â National Library of Medicine. MRI for early detection of stress fractures. Radiology. 2021;298(2):421â432.
- Brukner, P., & Khan, K. (2020). Clinical Sports Medicine. 6th ed. McGrawâHill.
- Sharrard, W. J. (2019). LowâIntensity Pulsed Ultrasound for Bone Healing: A Systematic Review. *J Orthop Res*, 37(11), 2345â2353.